Nona the Ninth by Tamsyn Muir (2022 St Martin’s Press Kindle 480pp)
Where to start with this one? I wanted to like it and at some points I liked it a lot but, in the end, it left me feeling a bit ‘meh’
This is the third book in Tamsyn Muir’s “The Locked Tomb” series and if you haven’t read the first two (“Gideon the Ninth” & “Harrow the Ninth”) then do not even think about picking this one up. Absolutely no recap is given and the reader is dumped straight into the story head-first. Even after reading the preceding books, I was confused and found most of what was going on confusing. Probably a good idea to read the earlier books again before diving into this volume – I didn’t and now wish I had as the significance of certain characters’ past relationships and antagonisms had faded from my memory and I was left scratching my head for a large chunk of the plot.
Most of the novel is seen from the viewpoint of the titular Nona, a pure innocent who six months earlier woke up in someone else’s 19-year-old body and is being protected by a pair of women with familiar names from the earlier books. She works as a teacher-aide in a school located in a bombed-out, strife-torn city on a planet facing impending doom. Unlike the setting of the earlier books, we seem to be in a near contemporary civilisation with such things as cars, guns, radio and TV.
Nona hangs out with a gang of kids younger than herself each with odd nicknames like “Hot Sauce” and “Beautiful Ruby”. She gets involved with their schemes and adventures as their society slowly falls apart.
Also active on this world are the “Blood of Eden” militants that oppose the Empire which tries to rule the remnants of mankind and its God-Emperor John Gaius. The Edenites consist of more characters I think I’m supposed to recall from the earlier books but couldn’t quite place.
After about 100 pages of this, things start to make a little more sense when some answers are given in info-dumps but I remained puzzled until the end.
Between chapters there is an account of a dream-like experience where Harrow (I think) is talking to John Gaius and we slowly learn the story of his ascent to God-hood. While it was interesting to finally get some back-story, I think it fell flat in the end for me. Plus, the fact that it all seemed to kick off in rural New Zealand made me take it somewhat less than seriously.
In fact, Muir who hails from New Zealand is leaving little NZ-isms throughout the book like ‘Easter Eggs’ for her kiwi fans. As a New Zealander myself I found some of these moments very odd and I was often thrown out of the story by them.
The author is great at creating worlds and characters but her plots leave something to be desired for this reader. The rivalries and back-stabbing of a bunch of people all of which I disliked continue on from the previous books and I found them dreary and forgettable then and even more so in this volume.
Things started moving in a hurry towards some sort of conclusion a couple of hundred pages in but then it just became plodding and by around the 300-page mark I was just hoping it would end soon. There were still nuggets of fun stuff and good writing but by then I just didn’t care.
One more book to go in the series - will I bother after this?